Last reviewed: November 17, 2026.

The short answer: can you refinance with a PACE lien?

In most residential-PACE-active states, Fannie Mae, FHA, and VA require the PACE assessment to be paid off at closing of the refinance; Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae allow limited retention only when the PACE is genuinely subordinate under the program’s terms.

For nearly all homeowners with HERO, California FIRST, Ygrene-legacy, or Florida PACE assessments, that means absorbing the PACE balance into the new loan.

This article covers first-mortgage refinances. For second-lien products, see MRB’s guides to HELOCs on PACE-encumbered homes and closed-end home equity loans with a PACE lien.

Why a residential PACE lien blocks most first-mortgage refinances

A residential PACE assessment is billed through the county property tax roll. State statutes in California (Streets and Highways Code § 5913), Florida, and Missouri grant it lien priority equal to general property taxes, placing it ahead of any private first mortgage. And no lender funding a new first mortgage is going to sit behind an assessment that can accelerate and foreclose independently. Fannie, Freddie, FHA, and VA all encode that concern in underwriting rules.

Rate-and-term vs cash-out: why loan type matters

Loan type governs the math. Conventional and FHA cash-out refinances cap LTV at 80%, while rate-and-term paths run higher. See MRB’s conventional rate-and-term refinance overview for program ceilings. If the PACE balance is small and equity is strong, a rate-and-term that absorbs PACE usually works. But when PACE pushes the required loan past 80% LTV, the file needs a cash-out structure, Fannie’s retained-PACE workaround, or a different program.

Fannie Mae: payoff first, retained PACE only as fallback

Selling Guide B5-3.4-01 (last updated October 8, 2025, Announcement SEL-2025-08) states Fannie won’t purchase a mortgage on a property with an outstanding PACE loan unless the PACE program’s terms don’t provide for lien priority over the first mortgage. California, Florida, and Missouri statutes grant that priority, so the default outcome is payoff.

The Guide directs lenders to first qualify the borrower for a cash-out or limited cash-out refinance sized to retire the PACE. Only if the borrower can’t qualify for a loan amount sufficient to pay off the PACE does Fannie permit a limited cash-out refinance with the PACE retained. Retained PACE is excluded from CLTV but included in PITIA and DTI. The loan is delivered with Special Feature Code 173.

Here’s the practical reality: DU may return “Ineligible” when cash back at closing exceeds the greater of 1% of the new loan amount or $2,000 (Guide B2-1.3-03). The lender can still deliver under DU’s limited waiver when the file meets other Guide requirements. The borrower discloses priority PACE on Form 1003 Section 5a(E); the lender confirms current status in Section L1.

Freddie Mac: truly subordinate or paid in full

Freddie Mac’s Single-Family Seller/Servicer Guide, Sections 4301.8 and 4301.5, permits purchase of mortgages on PACE-encumbered properties only when the PACE obligation is, and will remain, in a truly subordinate lien position. But California, Florida, and Missouri PACE statutes grant priority equal to property taxes, so PACE in those states isn’t truly subordinate. Freddie requires payoff in full through a no-cash-out refinance (4301.5) or a cash-out refinance (4301.8). See MRB’s conventional cash-out refinance overview for the payoff structure.

Worth knowing: Freddie offers essentially no retained-PACE workaround for the three largest residential PACE states. A file that could close under Fannie’s SFC 173 fallback often can’t close at Freddie. The reverse happens in states where the local PACE program contractually waives priority against the first mortgage, which is uncommon but does occur.

FHA: PACE must be paid off through a refinance

HUD Mortgagee Letter 2017-18, incorporated into Handbook 4000.1 Section II.A.8.k.ii, provides that FHA generally doesn’t insure new forward mortgages on properties encumbered by a PACE obligation. The refinance exception allows PACE to be paid off at closing through either an FHA Rate-and-Term (Simple) Refinance or an FHA Cash-Out Refinance.

Standard FHA underwriting applies on top of the PACE payoff. The 80% LTV cap on FHA Cash-Out Refinance governs how much PACE can be absorbed in a cash-out structure, and the FHA cash-out refinance 12-month seasoning rule applies. UFMIP is 1.75% of the base loan amount, financed into the new loan. Annual MIP is 0.50% at 90% LTV or less on terms over 15 years for loans at or below $726,200, and 0.55% at over 95% LTV on terms over 15 years for loans at or below $726,200.

One more thing – FHA policy on PACE has shifted before. Confirm current Mortgagee Letter status on HUD.gov before relying on the exception.

VA: narrow conditional retention, otherwise payoff required

VA Circular 26-16-18 requires the VA-guaranteed loan to be in first-lien position. A PACE obligation may remain only when the PACE lien outranks the VA loan solely for delinquent regularly scheduled installments, not for the full PACE balance. California, Florida, and Missouri PACE statutes generally grant full super-priority, which exceeds what VA permits. So the practical result is payoff at closing.

VA also requires the PACE obligation in public records, appraiser analysis of PACE-funded improvements, collection as special assessment taxes under state law, and no transfer-restricting covenants. See MRB’s coverage of VA Type I vs Type II cash-out and net tangible benefit for related rules.

The equity test, worked

A refinance that absorbs PACE is arithmetic before it’s underwriting. Required new loan = existing first-mortgage balance + PACE payoff + financed closing costs. LTV = required new loan ÷ appraised value.

Say the appraised value is $450,000. Existing first-mortgage balance $300,000. PACE payoff $35,000. Closing costs at 3% of the new loan, roughly $11,000 financed. Required new loan lands around $346,000. LTV is 346,000 ÷ 450,000, or 76.9%. That fits the 80% ceilings on both conventional and FHA cash-out refinances.

But push PACE to $70,000 and hold the rest constant: the loan becomes about $382,000, LTV 84.9%, which exceeds both 80% cash-out ceilings. The file then needs a rate-and-term structure where LTV room is higher, Fannie’s SFC 173 exception, or a different program.

Payoff statement and closing mechanics

PACE payoff is funded from loan proceeds at closing. The settlement agent needs three numbers in writing from the PACE administrator or successor servicer (Renew Financial, Ygrene-successor servicer, or the county treasurer for programs that moved collection in-house): the current installment amount, any delinquent amount, and the total payoff including per-diem interest.

Administrators move slowly.

So is two weeks before closing enough runway? Rarely. Loan officers who close these files regularly request the payoff statement the same week the appraisal is ordered – before the file ever reaches underwriting, not after it comes back with conditions. After funding, the title company records the release or satisfaction. Delayed recording occasionally leaves PACE on the tax roll for one more billing cycle, which affects the new escrow impound, and that single extra billing cycle can quietly shift the impound math in ways that catch borrowers off guard at the first post-close statement.

State-specific notes

California: HERO legacy and AB 1284

Streets and Highways Code § 5913 and AB 1284 govern residential PACE. Legacy HERO, California FIRST, and Ygrene-serviced assessments (the three names you’ll see most often on a title report) dominate the current refinance pipeline. See MRB’s guide on Mello-Roos and special tax assessment liens for adjacent California lien issues.

Florida and Missouri

Florida residential PACE collections run through county tax collectors with super-priority similar to California’s. Missouri’s Property Assessed Clean Energy Act operates on the same structural basis. In both states, payoff at refinance closing is the standard outcome.

What the CFPB Regulation Z PACE rule changes (March 1, 2026)

The CFPB final rule, published January 10, 2025 in the Federal Register, implements Section 307 of the 2018 Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief and Consumer Protection Act. It applies Regulation Z’s ability-to-repay requirements under § 1026.43 to residential PACE transactions originated on or after March 1, 2026, declares PACE transactions are not qualified mortgages, and imposes TILA disclosures on creditors and on PACE companies substantially involved in the credit decision.

For readers refinancing today, the effect is narrow. PACE liens originated before March 1, 2026 are still handled under investor and insurer payoff rules. New PACE assessments after the effective date carry TILA disclosures and ATR underwriting, which slows new origination but doesn’t change how an existing PACE lien is treated at the refinance table.

When refinancing is not viable

Sometimes the equity test fails. Options include a shorter-term refinance that pays principal faster, a Fannie limited cash-out with SFC 173 when Fannie is the end investor, keeping the existing mortgage and paying PACE from non-mortgage funds, or waiting for appraised value to catch up. California readers should check current California Housing Finance Agency Homeowner Assistance Fund eligibility, since program funding changes.

And document everything. The current PACE payoff quote, the valuation, and the lender’s declination reason. A later refinance attempt is easier when the paper trail is clean.

Checklist before you apply

Before you apply, pull the current PACE payoff from the administrator along with a recent valuation, confirm the existing first-mortgage balance, and add payoff, balance, and estimated closing costs before dividing the total by the valuation. Compare against the 80% cash-out ceiling and the higher rate-and-term ceiling for the program in play. Confirm the county’s current PACE release process so the new escrow impound is set correctly. And confirm program-rule currency with the lender before application. Guidance from FHA, Fannie, Freddie, and VA on PACE moves.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay off my PACE loan to refinance my first mortgage?
In California, Florida, and Missouri, almost always yes. Fannie, FHA, and VA require payoff; Freddie requires payoff unless PACE is truly subordinate, which those state statutes don’t permit.

Can I refinance with an FHA loan if I have a HERO or PACE assessment?
Yes, through either an FHA Simple Refinance or FHA Cash-Out Refinance that pays off PACE at closing. The 80% LTV cap applies to the cash-out path.

Does Fannie Mae allow a refinance with a PACE lien still on title?
Only as a fallback. Fannie requires the lender to first attempt a refinance large enough to retire the PACE. When that fails, a limited cash-out refinance with retained PACE is permitted under Special Feature Code 173.

Will Freddie Mac buy a mortgage with a subordinate PACE assessment?
Only when PACE is genuinely subordinate under the program’s terms. In California, Florida, and Missouri, PACE isn’t subordinate, so Freddie requires payoff.

Can a VA loan close on a property with a PACE lien?
Rarely. VA allows retention only when PACE outranks the VA loan solely for delinquent installments, not the full balance. The three major PACE states grant full super-priority, forcing payoff.

What is Special Feature Code 173?
Fannie Mae’s delivery code for a limited cash-out refinance in which a priority PACE lien is retained on title because the borrower didn’t qualify for a larger refinance to retire it.

How do I get a PACE payoff statement and how long does it take?
Request it from the PACE administrator or successor servicer. Allow several weeks. Order it the same week the appraisal is ordered to avoid a closing delay.

Does the March 2026 CFPB rule affect my existing PACE loan?
No. The Regulation Z rule applies to PACE transactions originated on or after March 1, 2026. Existing liens are still governed by investor and insurer payoff rules at refinance.

This article is general education, not personalized advice. Loan terms vary by borrower and lender. Confirm specifics with a licensed loan officer and a tax professional before deciding.

About the MRB Team

Mortgage Refinancing Blog

Our guides are researched from primary sources — Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, the CFPB, HUD, and the VA — and sources are listed on every article. We don’t originate loans and we’re not licensed advisors; treat everything here as education, not advice.